A couple weeks back, a writer by the name of Aaron Leitko penned an endearing article for the Washington Post that posited the idea that indie rockers are embracing the jam scene in growing numbers and that “jamband” is no longer a dirty word. The article focused primarily on musicians, but also quoted none other than Rob Mitchum for comment – one of the quintessential critics at the mighty Pitchfork – who outed himself as a longtime Phish fan.

After keeping his phanhood under wraps for the early part of his near decade-long tenure at Pitchfork, Mitchum recently came out of the closet in a big way, committing his twitter feed as a channel to review every single Phish show from 1993 to present. A perfect candidate for our Writer’s Workshop column, we invited Rob to join us for our periodic segment to share his thoughts and stories about his career as a writer, the power of Pitchfork, and of course the Phish from Vermont.
Hidden Track: Might as well start at the beginning, how did you initially get the role at Pitchfork? Was that your first real music writing gig?
Rob Mitchum: I basically got the Pitchfork writing job by writing them hate mail. I was a poor lab tech living in very expensive Washington DC, and decided a good, free way to entertain myself at night was to start writing about music. I had written a few album and concert reviews for the Michigan Daily in college, but got busy with other collegiate activities and didn’t keep it up. Faced with a lot of free time (and having just read the Richard Meltzer anthology A Whore Just Like The Rest, which opened me up to entirely new ways of writing about music), I took it up again and wrote a couple practice reviews.
At the time (late 2001), there were probably a dozen different music websites I could have sent those “clips” to, but Pitchfork was my favorite, so I started there. Thinking (as many people do) that Pitchfork was made up of elitist assholes, I figured I needed to be an elitist asshole myself to get their attention, so I wrote an e-mail that basically said, “your reviews suck now, I can do better.” Ryan Schreiber, who at the time was the entire full-time staff of the site, wrote me back and said I was welcome to prove it by writing two reviews a week for him, for free. Then I had to grudgingly admit that I was actually a nice guy and very excited to write for them. My first review was the Royal Tenenbaums soundtrack, and nearly ten years later, here we are. READ ON for more of our chat with Rob Mitchum…