Spoon Keeps Hot Streak Alive With ‘Lucifer on the Sofa’ (ALBUM REVIEW)

Spoon is possibly the most consistent band of the last 30 years. They’ve released ten albums since 1996, with only 2010’s Transference registering as anything close to a dip. Their greatest albums, A Series of Sneaks, Kill the Moonlight, Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga and They Want My Soul are spread out evenly amongst their only slightly less great companions. This would lead one to believe that Lucifer on the Sofa is due to become another tent pole, but would also lead someone to become very disappointed after listening to the first three songs here.

“Held” is a bluesy, setlist opener a ’la “Rent I Pay” and Divine Fits’ “Flaggin’ a Ride”; comparatively it’s a slower grower, but one that eventually earns its place as a lead-off. “The Hardest Cut”, a perfectly acceptable piece of modern radio fodder, sounds out of place for a band like Spoon, and “The Devil and Mr. Jones” feels like it could have been pulled right off Elvis Costello’s newest album, which isn’t exactly a compliment. These songs are good, but nevertheless, disappointments, and perhaps most aggravatingly, unnecessarily belittled by their sequencing. 

Lucifer on the Sofa is a very good Spoon album, one that borrows from They Want My Soul more than anything on Hot Thoughts, but none of that comes through until about 13 minutes in. That sequencing isolates the more straightforward rock tracks to limit their visceral appeal and doesn’t give the more cerebral highlights like “Astral Jacket” and the “Satellite” a chance to help out. The seven songs that follow “The Devil and Mr. Jones are great, each one seemingly better than the last before coming to a stunning close with the title track. This album could have easily become another classic from the band, but without the elevation those opening songs need, and the build-up that “Lucifer on the Sofa” deserves, it’ll remain just another notch in Spoon’s highly consistent streak.